|
|
| |
 |
 |
CHAPTER 3. |
|
| |
SUPPLY POTENTIAL OF FEEDSTOCK /BIOFUELS AND PRESENT
UTILISATION
|
|
| |
|
Malaysia is rich in both conventional (non-renewable) and non-conventional
(renewable) sources of energy. Two major sources of non-renewable energy are
petroleum and gas. It is projected that Malaysia will become a net importer by
2026, if new oil reserves are not discovered.
Palm products including biomass, palm oil and palm biofuel have been identified
as renewable fifth fuel under the 8th Malaysian Plan and the Third Outline
Perspective Plan from 2001 to 2010. The Malaysian Government is also
promoting renewable energy, especially from oil palm biomass as a move
towards a clean and environment-friendly alternative fuel.
Biofuel derived from renewable resources such as vegetable oils has been
recognized and accepted as one potential alternative energy. It covers biodiesel,
bio-ethanol, biogas, bio-oil, bio-methanol, etc. Amongst these, biodiesel (diesel
substitute) and bio-ethanol (gasoline or petrol substitute) have been identified as
having the greatest potential.
|
|
| |
|
3.1 Renewable Energy Sources in Malaysia |
| |
|
3.1.1 : Biomass / Agriculture Residue
Malaysia is well known as a biggest exporter of the palm oil in the world. In 2007,
Malaysia produced more than 15.8 million tonnes of crude palm oil and about 4.1
million tonnes of palm kernel. These are the 2 major products that being derived
from oil palm industry and it representing only about 10% of the total biomass
produced by the industry. The remaining, 90 % of it is in the form of
lignocellulosic material, whether in the form of EFB, palm frond, palm trunk,
palm shell, and palm oil mill effluents (POME) which are under utilized. These
biomass which accounting about more than 60 million (dry basis) is still
considered as a by product with little commercial values.
Currently there are 4.3 million hectares of oil palm planted in Malaysia with 406
palm oil mills in operation throughout Malaysia in 2007. Based on the crude
palm oil production in 2007 (20% on oil extraction rate) which is 15.2 million
tonnes, it is estimated that 17.5 million tones (moisture ~ 65%) of empty fruit
bunches (EFB) is generated and the potential energy that can be harnessed
from these EFB as a boiler fuel is estimated about 4 million tones of oil
equivalent (MTOE). While the energy generated from biogas of the anaerobic
palm oil mill effluent treatment is also a potential energy resources especially for
electricity generation. Table 5 and 6 show a number of palm oil mill in Malaysia
and the supply outlook of biomass from oil palm industry.
Table 5 : Palm Oil Mills in Malaysia in 2007
Malaysia also encourage the industry to turning these biomass for the power
generation for the grid connection under the Small Renewable Energy
Programme (SREP) and currently a few small power plant based on biomass is
being constructed and in operation with the capacity ranges from 10 MW to 15
MW and this plant has been built throughout Malaysia. SREP plants that using
the EFB as a boiler fuel need to consider the logistic supply of the EFB and
also the nearest grid connection available for the economic viability of the project.
Currently there are 22 plants under SREP being constructed by the private
company that using the biomass. Electricity generated by the renewable energy
based on the biomass and agriculture residues currently represent more than
5% of all prime energy used as targeted by Malaysian government.
Table 6 : Oil Palm Biomass supply Outlook in Peninsular Malaysia (2007 -2020)
| Year |
Felled trunk (mill.tonnes/yr) |
Prunned frond
(mill.tonnes/yr) |
EFB (mill. tonnes/yr) |
| 2007-2010 |
3.23 |
6.89 |
282 |
| 2011-2013 |
4.28 |
6.80 |
2.83 |
| 2014-2016 |
3.58 |
7.05 |
2.91 |
| 2017-2020 |
2.97 |
7.14 |
2.81 |
At present, biomass fuels account for about 16% of the energy consumption in
the country, of which 51% is from palm oil biomass and 22% from wood waste.
Biomass-based power generation capacity in the country stands at 138 MW, of
which 100 MW is used in the palm oil industry
RE contributions to the national economy from biomass alone can reach up to
RM 10 billion per year. Even with only a 5% RE share of the national electricity
generation, the country saves RM 2.8 billion in coal import costs over 20 years.
The Ninth Malaysia Plan calls for the further development and utilizations of RE
resources by supporting initiatives such as the Small Renewable Energy Power
Programme (SREP) and Renewable Energy Power Purchase Agreement
(REPPA). By 2010, RE is expected to generate and connect about 300 MW of
power to the grid in Peninsula Malaysia; with 50MW added to the grid in Sabah.
The Plan also encourages other RE sources, such as solar hybrids and the
expansion of biomass co-generation.
3.1.2 Others source of renewable energy
Others sources of renewable energy such as solar, wind, thermal energy and
PV are contributed a small portion of the electricity generated. Most of them
being used for in house uses such as for water heating or for drying of crops
product.
However the hydropower has contributed a significant portion (9.4%) for the
electricity generated in Malaysia. Table 7 shows a major hydro power station in
Malaysia with their installed capacity.
Table 7 : Installed capacity of major hydro power station in Malaysia
| Station |
Installed Capacity
(MW) |
- 1. Trengganu
- Kenyir
|
400.0 |
- Perak
- Temenggor
- Bersia
- Kenering
- Sg. Piah
|
348.0
72.0
160.5
68.6
|
- Pahang
- Sultan Yusof
- Sultan Idris
- Cameron
|
100.0
150.0
11.9
|
- Kelantan
- Pergau
- Kenerong
|
600.0
20.0
|
- Sabah
- Tenom Pangi
|
66.0 |
- Sarawak
- Batang Ai
|
94.0 |
Total
|
2,091.0 |
|
|
| |
|
3.2 Malaysian Palm Biofuels Research Programme |
| |
|
Malaysia has embarked on an extensive biodiesel research programme since
1982. The palm biodiesel programme includes development of production
technology to convert palm oil into methyl esters (palm biodiesel), pilot plant
study of palm biodiesel production as well as exhaustive evaluation of palm
biodiesel as diesel substitute in conventional diesel engines (both stationary and
exhaustive field trials) locally and overseas. Malaysian Palm Oil Board (MPOB)
has developed a technology to produce normal-grade palm biodiesel from palm
oil and its derivatives (Figure 2). It can be used directly as fuel in unmodified
diesel engines. However, this palm biodiesel has a pour point of 150C and this
has confined its utilization to tropical countries only.

Figure 2: Palm Biodiesel
MPOB has also developed another technology to produce a winter-grade palm biodiesel (pour point of -18 to -20 degree C) to overcome the pour point problem of normal palm biodiesel. The winter-grade palm biodiesel can be used in temperate countries. Both normal and low pour point palm biodiesel produced using MPOB developed technologies exhibit quality that meets the European Biodiesel Standard (EN 14214) and the United States Biodiesel Standard (ASTM D6751) (Table 8).
Table 8: Product Specifications of Palm Biodiesel (Normal and Winter Grade
| Property |
Unit |
Palm
Biodiesel |
EN 14214 |
ASTM D6751 |
| Ester Content |
% m/m |
>98.5 |
96.5 min |
- |
| Sulfur Content |
mg/kg |
<10 |
10 max |
15 max |
| Carbon Residue (on 10% distillation residue) |
% m/m |
0.2 |
0.30 |
- |
| Carbon Residue |
% mass |
- |
- |
0.05 max |
| Sulfated Ash |
% mass |
<0.01 |
0.02 max |
0.02 max |
| Cetane Number |
- |
58.2 |
51.0 min |
47 min |
| Monoglycerides |
% m/m |
0.4-0.65 |
0.80 max |
- |
| Diglycerides |
|
<0.2 |
0.20 max |
- |
| Triglycerides |
|
<0.1 |
0.20max |
- |
| Na+K |
mg/kg |
<5 |
5.0 max |
- |
| Ca + Mg |
|
<4 |
|
|
| Phosphorus |
|
<10 |
10.0 max |
10.0 max |
| Methanol Content |
% m/m |
<0.2 |
0.2 max |
- |
| Water Content |
mg/kg |
300-400 |
500 max |
- |
Figure 3: MPOB Palm Biodiesel Pilot Plant
| |
| |
|
3.3 Current Developments on Palm Biodiesel |
| |
|
There has been a lot of interest from Malaysian companies, foreign companies and joint ventures in setting up biodiesel plants in the country. In an effort to kick-start the biodiesel industry in Malaysia in order to stay ahead in the development of this new industry, MPOB itself is building three commercial palm biodiesel plants (each comprising of normal and low-pour point palm biodiesel plants) based on its own technology and lease to three private companies upon completion. Two plants have been successfully commissioned in July 2006 and April 2007. The third plant has been successfully commissioned in February 2008. Products obtained from the three plants meet EN14214 and ASTM 6751 specifications.
Plants based on various other technologies are also being constructed in the country. To date, 91 biodiesel manufacturing licence have been approved with a total annual planned capacity of 10.2 million tonnes. As of end August 2008, 15 biodiesel plants have been established with a total annual approved production capacity of 1.65 million tonnes. Commercial production of palm biodiesel commenced in August 2006 and most of the palm biodiesel produced so far are exported.
Table 9 shows the biodiesel plant with installed capacity in Malaysia .
Table 9 : Biodiesel plant in Malaysia
| No. |
Company |
Location |
Approved
capacity
(Tonnes/Year) |
1. |
Carotino Sdn. Bhd. |
Johor |
180,000 |
2. |
Vance Bioenergy Sdn. Bhd. |
Johor |
300,000 |
3. |
Malaysian Vegetable Oil Refinery Sdn. Bhd. |
Johor |
100,000 |
4. |
PGEO Bioproducts Sdn.Bhd. |
Johor |
100,000 |
5. |
Nexsol(Malaysia) Sdn. Bhd. |
Johor |
100,000 |
6. |
Golden Hope Biodiesel Sdn. Bhd. |
Selangor |
90.000 |
7. |
Zoop Sdn. Bhd. |
Selangor |
100,000 |
8. |
Titian Asli Sdn. Bhd. |
Selangor |
60,000 |
9. |
Global Bio-Diesel Sdn. Bhd. |
Sabah |
150,000 |
10. |
SPC Biodiesel Sdn. Bhd. |
Sabah |
100,000 |
11. |
Mission Biotechnologies Sdn. Bhd. |
Pahang |
99,000 |
12. |
Plant Biofuels Corporation Sdn. Bhd. |
Pahang |
100,000 |
13. |
Carotech Bio-Fuel Sdn. Bhd. |
Perak |
93,000 |
14. |
Lereno Sdn. Bhd. |
Perak |
60,000 |
15. |
Ganz Biofuels Sdn.Bhd.(Platinum Energy) |
N.S. |
18,000 |
| |
TOTAL |
|
1,650,000 |
It is estimated that a total of 10 million tonnes of palm oil will be consumed annually should all the approved projects start operations. Feedstock for the approved biodiesel projects is mainly from processed palm oil with about 6 million tonnes estimated to be consumed per year. The other raw materials are crude palm oil and palm fatty acid distillate.
|
|
| |
|
3.4. Global Demand for Palm Biodiesel |
| |
|
Malaysia has great potential to be one of the major players in the global biodiesel demand. Currently, the demand is from overseas, especially EU and USA. In the foreseeable future, the market potential is huge and the main markets for biodiesel are still in EU and USA. In EU, biodiesel continues to be the preferred and leading alternative to conventional fuels, although bio-ethanol is starting to make in-roads. The 'Biofuel Directive' basically requires member states to increase the use of biofuels to a minimum of 2% of total liquid fuel consumption by 2005, and progressively increase it further to 5.75% by 2010. By 2010, EU needs 10.2 millions tones of biodiesel. These targets are non-mandatory, but require all EU member states to annually report their progress on implementation with close monitoring by the EU authorities on the level of achievement in the targets. These targets serve as a strong political signal and indicate the determination and commitment of the EU member states to the use of biofuels.
The other potential big market is US. Currently US produced 75 million gallons of biodiesel which represents a mere 0.12% of total US diesel demand. A B5 blend will require about 3 billion gallons of biodiesel. To produce 3 billion gallons of biodiesel requires about 10.2 million tones of oils and fats as raw materials.
|
|
| |
|
3.5 Potential Market for Palm Biodiesel in Malaysia |
| |
|
The potential market for biodiesel in Malaysia is not very certain at present. The
Government has yet to make decision on the implementation of biodiesel
blended with diesel for local use. Total diesel consumption in Malaysia is about
10 million tonnes a year. If a mandatory 5% blend is implemented, then this will
take up 500,000 tonnes of biodiesel. If this blend is increased to 10% then it will
be 1 million tonnes per year; and if 20%, then 2 million tonnes per year.
Besides this mandatory blending, industrial users may voluntarily use higher
percentage of biodiesel or even 100% if the price is right. Currently, the biodiesel
price is still higher than the unsubsidized petroleum diesel price.
Table 10. : Annual consumption of diesel in Malaysia and biodiesel requirement
Secter |
Diesel
(Billion Liters) |
Requirement of palm
biodiesel for B5 |
| (Billion Liters) |
(Tonnes) |
Retail Pump Stations |
5.878 |
0.294 |
258,651 |
Fleet Transport Operators |
0.344 |
0.017 |
15,127 |
River Passenger Boats |
0.120 |
0.006 |
5,300 |
Fisheries |
1.285 |
0.064 |
56,546 |
Industries |
4.027 |
0.201 |
177,202 |
TOTAL |
11.655 |
0.583 |
512,825 |
Note:
1 tonne of biodiesel is equivalent to 1,136 litres biodiesel at density of 0.88kg/litre
Source : KPDN HEP
|
|
| |
|
3.6 Future of Palm Biodiesel |
| |
|
The world cannot produce enough vegetable oil for biodiesel to replace
petroleum diesel. Therefore, in principle, all vegetable oils will have a role to play
in the global biodiesel industry. The key factor will be availability at competitive
price and supply. In this respect, palm oil has significant advantages over other
vegetable oils.
Malaysia produces an excess of palm oil for its own needs. Currently about 90%
of the palm oil produced is exported, with the major markets being China, EU,
Pakistan, India, Egypt, USA, Bangladesh and Japan. Currently the national
stock level stands at 1.3 million tonnes. There is therefore assured availability of
palm oil for biofuel use at present.
In terms of price competitiveness, historically palm oil was traded at a large
discount against most other vegetable oils especially rapeseed and soybean oils.
Rapeseed and soybean oils are the two main raw materials for the production of
biodiesel in the world. However, this discount has vanished in recent months
(Figure 4).
Malaysia has good facilities for the development of a biodiesel industry because
it has a highly developed palm oil refining and oleochemical industries.
Furthermore, Malaysia also produces methanol which is an important ingredient
in the production of biodiesel from its natural gas.
Oil palm is the most productive oil bearing plant species known, and it is less
prone to the vagaries of the weather unlike other vegetable oils such as soybean
and rapeseed. Being a perennial tree crop, it produces oil the whole year round
and is not deleterious to the environment like the annual crops. This is an added
advantage as a constant supply of raw material for the biodiesel industry can be
ensured. Oil palm is regarded as the most cost-effective vegetable oil crop as it
has the highest yield and most economical oil. The yield of palm oil is 3.8 tonnes
of palm oil per hectare per year (Table 11)
Table 11: Oil Yield
|
Yield(tonnes/ha/yr) |
Palm Oil (Malaysia) |
3.80* |
Rapeseed(EU) |
1.33** |
Soyabean(USA) |
0.46** |
Sunflower(Argentina) |
0.66** |
Jatropha |
3.00*** |
Source: *MPOB (2005) **Khoo(2001) ***Stefan Preusser (2006)
The production of palm biodiesel will open up more opportunities for the Malaysia
palm oil industry. Palm oil is very unique and the resulting palm biodiesel
produced by MPOB's patented process contain two very high-value components,
that is carotenoids and vitamin E. MPOB has successfully developed processes
to recover these valuable products. It is estimated that, if the carotenes and
vitamin E are recovered, the income generated from the sales of the carotenes
and vitamin E recovered is able to pay for the investment. This will make the
palm biodiesel as by products. At the same time Malaysia can be the major
player of the global phytonutrients industry.
|
|
 |
|